A federal judge acquitted two brothers after prosecutors failed to prove a material misrepresentation, leaving broader questions about transaction-ordering conduct and tokenized-market safeguards unresolved.
A federal judge’s acquittal of Anton and James Peraire-Bueno turned on a basic requirement of wire-fraud law: prosecutors had to prove a material misrepresentation. U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke concluded they had not, ending the criminal case without a retrial after a jury deadlocked in an earlier proceeding, according to Reuters and Decrypt. Clarke issued the acquittal on Nov. 16, 2026.
The brothers, who were educated at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, faced charges of wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering. Prosecutors alleged they exploited a vulnerability in infrastructure used to process Ethereum transactions, extracting value from trading bots through transaction ordering. The specific amount and timing are not established in the available reporting and should not be treated as settled facts.
Clarke’s ruling addressed the government’s proof, not the legality of cryptocurrency markets as a whole. As described in the reports, prosecutors did not show the material misrepresentation required for their wire-fraud theory. Clarke said the transactions, on the evidence presented, did not amount to false promises or criminal fraud. She left open whether the conduct could be unethical or violate other laws.
An acquittal means the prosecution did not establish the charged offenses to the required standard on this record. It does not create a general license to exploit trading systems, resolve every legal question about maximum extractable value (MEV), or decide potential civil and regulatory claims. As a district court ruling, it also does not bind courts nationwide. Its immediate effect is that this prosecution is over; the treatment of similar conduct will depend on the facts and laws involved.
MEV is value gained by changing the ordering, inclusion or exclusion of transactions in a blockchain block. The practice can be visible in transaction mechanics yet difficult to characterize under traditional fraud statutes. The government’s burden was not simply to show that the defendants took advantage of a technical opening or caused losses. It had to prove the elements of the crimes charged, including deception for wire fraud. An allegedly harmful outcome alone does not establish a material misrepresentation.
The case has implications for Wall Street’s tokenization efforts, but Clarke did not rule on tokenized securities. A separate SEC framework, described in recent reporting, allows tokenized-stock venues to set their own MEV safeguards while requiring disclosure of whether policies exist, known material risks, mitigation or compensation arrangements, and monitoring for trading abuse—or the absence of monitoring.
Such disclosures can inform investors about transaction-ordering risks and a venue’s approach to potential losses. They do not determine whether a trader’s conduct amounts to criminal wire fraud. That question depends on statutory requirements and evidence in a particular case. The reported framework also permits differing approaches to safeguards and loss recovery; disclosure is not a uniform protection or a guarantee against losses.
The decision thus marks a limited boundary between market harm and criminal deception. Prosecutors may pursue conduct they consider abusive, but allegations cannot replace proof of each required element. For firms building tokenized markets, the ruling is a reason to attend to controls and disclosures, not assurance that any particular safeguard prevents liability. Clarke’s decision clarifies what the prosecution failed to prove; it does not settle how existing law applies to evolving trading systems.

