District attorneys and victims’ relatives are asking California’s Supreme Court to block Gov. Gavin Newsom’s death-row commutations, arguing that required safeguards were bypassed.
A dispute over Gov. Gavin Newsom’s death-row commutations is testing the limits of a California governor’s clemency power—and the safeguards state law requires before it is used.
The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation filed a writ petition with the California Supreme Court on Sunday, Nov. 15, asking it to block the commutations and grant permanent relief. As of Nov. 16, the court had not said whether it would hear the case. The petition was filed directly with the state’s highest court rather than through the ordinary appeals process, the Sacramento Bee reported.
The plaintiffs include district attorneys from 30 counties and more than two dozen relatives of murder victims, according to NBC News. Victims’-rights groups, police organizations and prosecutors’ organizations are also part of the coalition.
The petition argues Newsom made a categorical decision based on opposition to capital punishment rather than reviewing each case individually. Plaintiffs also say required investigations should have been referred to the Board of Parole Hearings and that the governor cannot use unilateral action to bypass constitutional and statutory safeguards. Those are claims in the petition, not findings by a court.
The coalition cites what it describes as a possible error in the case review: plaintiffs say they have identified at least one inmate listed as having one felony conviction who may have two. They argue the discrepancy could affect the required review process. The allegation has not been established by a court.
Newsom’s office referred Courthouse News to the governor’s Nov. 5 statement defending the action as consistent with how previous governors and presidents have used clemency. That position sets up a dispute over the reach of executive authority and the procedures that constrain it.
The case is a state-governance test, not a clash over federal preemption. The reports available do not identify a federal action controlling the commutations. Instead, California’s Supreme Court is being asked to interpret the state’s rules and determine whether the governor followed them.
Clemency is exercised by governors under state law, but its boundaries depend on each state’s constitutional structure, statutes and judicial interpretation. California’s justices will have to weigh the governor’s defense of his authority against the plaintiffs’ claims about individual review and required safeguards.
The case may offer other states a point of comparison, though clemency systems and procedures vary. The available reporting does not show that another state is copying Newsom’s approach or proposing a similar policy. Any broader significance will depend on whether the California court takes the case and how it explains the limits of the governor’s power.
For now, the legal outcome remains open. The petition asks the justices to halt implementation and grant permanent relief, but the court had not said whether it would hear the challenge. The governor’s defense and the plaintiffs’ procedural objections remain competing arguments awaiting judicial review.

