A proposed Donbas-for-NATO formula and rising risks around the Strait of Hormuz expose difficult choices for Washington and its allies.
Two tests of American power sharpened Sunday: whether NATO membership could anchor a settlement over Ukraine’s territory, and whether Washington can contain its confrontation with Iran without increasing risks to Gulf shipping and U.S. personnel.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said on November 15 that U.S. negotiators had raised a new possibility in talks: Ukraine withdrawing from the remaining Ukrainian-held part of Donbas in exchange for NATO membership. Zelenskyy said it was the first time the idea had been raised in negotiations.
Kyiv has not accepted the proposal. Zelenskyy said Ukraine would consider a referendum only with binding security guarantees, a strong Ukrainian military and reconstruction funding. The conditions reflect the central difficulty of any deal: a territorial concession would need to be matched by protection against a renewed Russian attack.
Moscow’s stated demands leave little room for an easy bargain. Russia continues to seek all of Donbas and opposes Ukraine joining NATO. President Vladimir Putin also told U.S. envoys that foreign troops in Ukraine would be unacceptable, Bloomberg reported on November 14–15. The positions remain far apart, and the proposal is not an agreement.
For Washington and NATO, the question is whether membership could deter another Russian attack—or create a new security obligation without a durable settlement. Zelenskyy’s conditions show Kyiv wants a commitment backed by military strength and resources, not a symbolic offer. Russia’s opposition to both membership and foreign forces underscores the risk that Moscow would resist the safeguards Ukraine seeks.
The confrontation with Iran presents a more immediate operational danger. Iran’s navy said three oil tankers caught fire on November 14 after striking naval mines in the Strait of Hormuz. Reuters said it could not independently verify the reports. ABC News reported Sunday that the United States was enforcing a naval blockade of Iranian ports in the Persian Gulf and Gulf of Oman, while Iran claimed control of the strait.
Iran’s Revolutionary Guard Corps also claimed six drones targeted Bahrain’s Riffa helicopter base. That claim, like the reported mine incidents, has not been independently confirmed in the supplied reporting. Reuters said Gulf markets were reacting to the disruption and attacks on Saudi Arabia by Iran-aligned Houthis.
The stakes reach well beyond the immediate military exchanges. Hormuz is a major oil-shipping route, and sustained disruption could affect energy markets and commercial traffic. Washington and its partners would then face the challenge of protecting shipping while avoiding further escalation. The risks come as the United States reduces staffing at four Middle East embassies after intelligence indicated Iran had substantially increased efforts to target U.S. personnel.
Alliance coordination is another concern. PBS NewsHour reported that U.S. allies were not consulted before the Iran war began. Partners expected to manage the consequences of a campaign but excluded from the decision to launch it may be less prepared to coordinate when a crisis deepens.
A separate dispute over Nvidia chips points to the economic side of competition with China. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent blamed Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick’s department for not restricting Nvidia sales to China. Megaspeed, a major chip buyer, has drawn scrutiny over its global footprint and possible links to the Chinese government. The company denied wrongdoing and said Alice Huang left in 2025; the available reporting does not establish that Megaspeed acted for Beijing.
Across these fronts, U.S. leverage depends on credible commitments, secure trade routes and coordination with allies. Ukraine’s security terms remain unresolved, while the claims surrounding Hormuz require verification. The actions governments take next will determine whether these crises produce deterrence or wider instability.

