Texas Sen. John Cornyn says he will block Elliot Gaiser’s nomination to a Dallas-area federal court vacancy by withholding his blue slip. Cornyn says Gaiser was not vetted by the bipartisan evaluation committee traditionally used in Texas and that the White House did not consult him. The White House has requested information about Cornyn’s preferred candidate, Fort Worth lawyer Steve Fahey, but no decision on a replacement is reported. Senate Republicans are trying to fill remaining federal court vacancies before Democrats assume power in January, while the status of Gaiser’s nomination remains uncertain. The next steps are to clarify whether Gaiser will be withdrawn and whether another nominee will be considered.
TLDR: Cornyn is withholding the home-state approval that would help Elliot Gaiser’s Texas judicial nomination advance, citing a lack of consultation and traditional screening. The White House has asked about Cornyn’s preferred candidate, Steve Fahey, but the vacancy’s next steps remain unresolved.
Texas Sen. John Cornyn says he will block President Donald Trump’s nominee for a Dallas-area federal court vacancy, keeping a familiar Texas review process at the center of the dispute. Cornyn has not returned the “blue slip” for Elliot Gaiser, a senior Justice Department official nominated earlier this month, and says he does not plan to do so. The move comes as Senate Republicans work to fill remaining federal court vacancies before Democrats assume power in January.
Cornyn’s stated reason is that a lifetime judicial appointment requires consultation and vetting, including review by the bipartisan federal judicial evaluation committee traditionally used in Texas. He says Gaiser is not from Texas, was not vetted through that process and is not the best-qualified candidate. Cornyn describes consultation as part of the Senate’s constitutional responsibility to provide advice and consent.
A blue slip is a permission from home-state senators that allows a judicial nominee to advance in the confirmation process. It gives those senators substantial power to block a president’s court picks. Cornyn’s refusal therefore creates a procedural barrier to Gaiser’s nomination. The Senate is also facing a limited window to act on vacancies before the January change in power.
Gaiser leads the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel. Texas Sen. Ted Cruz’s staff first contacted him about becoming a federal judge on Nov. 4, the day after the election, according to Gaiser’s questionnaire to the Senate Judiciary Committee. He was nominated for the Dallas-area vacancy earlier this month. The account does not say whether the White House consulted Cornyn before the nomination. Cornyn says he was not consulted.
The White House has requested information about Cornyn’s preferred candidate, Fort Worth lawyer Steve Fahey. Fahey served in the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Northern District of Texas from 2003 to 2021. He later worked as a partner at Kirkland and Ellis and started his own firm in 2024. Cornyn has not said whether Gaiser will be formally withdrawn. The White House’s request does not establish that Fahey will be nominated.
The dispute puts two priorities in tension: filling a federal court vacancy before the Senate’s political balance changes, and following the consultation and screening process Cornyn says is customary in Texas. Moving quickly could help the Senate address vacancies before January. Cornyn’s position asserts a home-state senator’s role and the value of a bipartisan evaluation process. It could also leave the Dallas-area seat unfilled while another candidate is considered.
Cornyn says he does not want the court seat to remain vacant. He has described Gaiser as bright and said he has a promising future, while also expressing concern that Gaiser had been used as a pawn in the process. Those remarks distinguish Cornyn’s objection to how the nomination was handled from a claim that Gaiser lacks ability. His stated concern is that the process did not include the local consultation and vetting he considers necessary for a lifetime appointment.
The practical impact described so far is procedural. The available account does not state any fees, new forms, compliance costs or specific confirmation deadline for Gaiser. His nominee questionnaire was sent to the Senate Judiciary Committee, and the blue slip is the key step Cornyn says he will withhold. The immediate consequence is that Gaiser’s nomination cannot advance through that route while Cornyn maintains his position. The account does not say whether another route is available.
The vacancy remains unresolved, and timing matters because Senate Republicans are seeking to fill remaining federal court vacancies before Democrats take power in January. The White House has asked for information about Fahey, but Gaiser’s nomination status remains uncertain. The next steps are to determine whether Gaiser is formally withdrawn and whether another nominee is considered. The available account does not identify a later deadline or a formal oversight schedule. The nomination and the vacancy will need further review as the Senate considers how to proceed.

