The Commerce Department has introduced a licensing requirement for advanced semiconductor exports, re-exports and transfers to Brazil, Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore and Thailand. It says the rule is aimed at closing a route that could send chips to China through an intermediary. Former department officials allege that enforcement under Howard Lutnick was weak and that suspicious activity went unaddressed, but Commerce did not respond to a request for comment. A research estimate and other published reports describe substantial alleged chip diversion, though those figures are not department enforcement findings. The new rule adds a compliance step, while the available account does not state fees, forms, processing times or penalties.
TLDR: A new Commerce Department rule requires licenses for advanced semiconductor shipments involving five countries, with the stated aim of closing a possible route to China. Former officials allege enforcement failures, but their claims remain unverified and the department had not responded to a request for comment.
The Commerce Department has imposed a new licensing rule for advanced semiconductor shipments to five countries, while former department officials question whether export restrictions were enforced effectively under Secretary Howard Lutnick. Their accounts describe internal disorder and missed chances to act on suspected chip smuggling. The claims have not been independently resolved in the material available, and Commerce did not respond to a request for comment.
The department’s stated rationale for the new rule is to close a route through which advanced chips could be exported to China through an intermediary country. Commerce has a national security role in investigating and enforcing bans on exports of advanced chips to China and other U.S. adversaries. The chips can be used in artificial intelligence and sophisticated weapons.
On Monday, the department required licenses for exporting, re-exporting or transferring advanced semiconductors to Brazil, Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore and Thailand. The rule addresses a concern that products shipped to third countries could then reach China. The department had previously said it would strengthen AI chip export controls through guidance to industry and the public after rolling back a broader rule in May 2025.
Four former Commerce officials spoke with CBS News anonymously, saying they feared professional reprisals. One alleged that agency enforcement officers found suspicious activity at Southeast Asian sites where Nvidia chips had been delivered, but that department directors took no action. Another said no companies were added to the federal Entity List for a full year, the first such gap in 18 years, according to that former official.
The Entity List identifies firms barred from buying the most advanced chips because of concerns that they could route them to China or other adversaries. Placement on the list triggers stricter license requirements. The Federal Register shows the last additions were made on Oct. 9, 2025, while the previous yearlong gap was in 2008. Those records establish the timing of list additions, but do not by themselves settle the former officials’ claims about why the gap occurred or what action was warranted.
The former officials’ allegations come amid wider scrutiny of chip exports. An April 2026 estimate by the AI research nonprofit Epoch put the number of cutting-edge chips smuggled into China in 2024 and 2025 between 290,000 and 1.6 million. The study described that amount as roughly a quarter of China’s computing power acquired through legal channels or domestic production. The estimate is a research finding, not a department enforcement tally.
Other reports cited in the account also describe alleged diversion. The Information reported that at least $7.5 billion in Nvidia chips allegedly reached Chinese companies since 2023 through companies linked to Alice Huang, a woman U.S. intelligence agencies believed to be a Chinese spy. The report cited sources close to Huang for its estimate. China denied the spying accusation, calling it an attempt to smear China.
A former OpenAI researcher also published a paper claiming to have found digital forensic evidence that leading Chinese AI models were trained using Nvidia chips banned in China. Separately, former Commerce staff said policy changes were sometimes learned through media reports, including a shift that allowed sales to China of Nvidia’s H20 and H200 chips, described in the account as the company’s second-most advanced tier of graphics processors. These claims and descriptions remain attributed to their sources.
The policy path has changed across administrations. The Biden administration issued AI chip export controls in 2022 and 2023, then issued an interim final rule in January 2025 to block China and other adversaries from obtaining the most advanced chips directly or through third countries. In May 2025, the Trump Commerce Department rolled that rule back, arguing it would have stifled American innovation. The department said it would instead strengthen controls through guidance.
Former officials also said experienced staff departures weakened the department’s capacity. Matthew Borman, who had served for more than 30 years, and Eileen Albanese, a longtime director of the Office of National Security Controls, left soon after Lutnick took office. The former officials said as many as 50 skilled staff members departed over 18 months. They also alleged that senior management created a bottleneck in enforcement; the department did not respond to CBS News’ request for comment, and the White House was also contacted.
The practical impact of Monday’s rule is a license requirement for covered exports, re-exports and transfers to five named countries. That adds a compliance step for parties handling advanced semiconductors, but the account gives no fee, application form, processing time or deadline. It also does not specify penalties or describe how many companies or shipments will be affected. Those details are not reported in the available material.
The allegations about enforcement and staffing remain serious but unverified in the account, and the department’s response was not available. The new licensing requirement is in effect, while the excerpt provides no separate schedule for future changes or formal review. Compliance with the rule and continued scrutiny of export enforcement are necessary steps; the department’s next actions and any official response remain to be seen.

