New York City’s law to end Central Park’s horse-drawn carriage rides by June 2028 is facing a federal lawsuit from the union representing drivers. The union argues that the ban is unconstitutional, violates local legal procedures and threatens workers’ livelihoods; those claims have not been decided by a court. City officials have cited safety concerns in a busy park, including a fatal runaway-carriage incident last spring and earlier cases of horses collapsing or bolting. The city already requires veterinary checks, time off for horses and a retirement age. City Hall has promised a career transition plan next April with job training, education pathways and stipends, but details on eligibility and amounts are not yet available.
TLDR: The union representing Central Park carriage drivers has sued to block New York City’s law ending the rides by June 2028. The city cites safety concerns and has promised a transition plan next April, while the lawsuit’s claims and the plan’s details remain unresolved.
New York City’s plan to end Central Park’s horse-drawn carriage rides is now facing a federal lawsuit. The Transport Workers Union, which represents carriage drivers, filed suit in Manhattan on Thursday, shortly after Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed legislation to wind down the industry. The union is asking the court to strike down the ban and argues that the city is taking away drivers’ livelihoods. The city’s law department says it is reviewing the case.
The stated rationale for the law is safety in a busy public park. Mamdani said horses should no longer carry tourists among joggers, cyclists and other passersby in Central Park. City lawmakers renewed their push for a ban after an eighteen-year-old tourist died last spring after jumping from a runaway carriage. The city’s position, as described at the bill signing, is that changing conditions in the park call for a change in law.
The law is scheduled to stop carriage rides by June 2028. That leaves time before the ban takes effect, but it does not remove the uncertainty facing drivers and others in the industry. The lawsuit disputes the city’s authority to proceed as it did and argues that the law is unconstitutional. Those are claims made by the union, not findings by a court.
The case also raises questions about how the city handled legal interests tied to the business. The lawsuit says the city violated local legal procedures when it approved the law and names the mayor and other city officials as defendants. It describes the city’s approach as threatening owners’ property interests and contracts while leaving compensation unclear. The excerpt does not establish whether owners will receive compensation or whether a court will agree with the union’s account.
The dispute follows a long-running argument over the rides. Animal welfare activists and supporters of the industry have disagreed over whether the carriages represent cruelty or a surviving link to the city’s past. The city has already imposed safety rules, including veterinary checkups, required vacation time for horses and a retirement age for the animals. Those measures show that regulation has been part of the industry for years, though the new law goes further by setting an end date for the rides.
Safety concerns include horses collapsing or becoming startled and running into cars or other objects. The death of Romanch Mahajan prompted lawmakers to renew the ban effort, and the account describes it as apparently the first fatality in a horse-carriage accident since the rides began in Central Park. That description is qualified in the source material. The reported facts explain the policy’s safety rationale, but they do not settle the separate legal dispute over the ban or its effects on workers.
City Hall has promised a career transition plan for people in the carriage industry next April. The plan is expected to include job training, educational pathways and stipends. Union leader John Samuelsen said the protections described by the mayor should have been written into the legislation, while drivers argue their future remains uncertain. The available material does not specify the amount of any stipends, who will qualify, or how the transition programs will be administered.
The practical impacts are direct: carriage rides are set to end by June 2028, and drivers and other people in the industry face a change to their work and livelihoods. Existing requirements include veterinary checks, time off for horses and an animal retirement age. The source gives no new application forms, fees, enforcement process or compliance penalties under the ban, and it does not state what compensation, if any, owners will receive. The transition plan’s promised training, education options and stipends are the stated steps for affected workers, with further details not yet provided.
The lawsuit now places the law’s constitutionality and approval process before the federal court in Manhattan. The city law department is reviewing the case, while City Hall’s transition plan is expected next April and the ban is set for June 2028. Those are the next steps identified in the account; the court’s decision and the plan’s details remain unresolved. The legal review and the coming transition plan will determine how the city proceeds and what support is available to people affected.

