A federal judge declined to block New York’s enforcement case against Kalshi, leaving the dispute over federal commodities law and state gambling authority for further proceedings.
A federal judge has rejected the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s second emergency effort to stop New York from pursuing an enforcement case against prediction-market operator Kalshi. The decision leaves the state’s case on track for consideration in state court and does not resolve whether the contracts Kalshi offers violate New York law.
U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield ruled Nov. 20 that the CFTC had not shown a likelihood of success on its argument that the federal Commodity Exchange Act preempts state gambling laws. That finding was the basis for denying the agency’s request for emergency relief. It is not a final ruling on the reach of the federal statute or on the merits of New York’s allegations.
The ruling came a day after U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick sent New York’s case against Kalshi to Manhattan state court, finding that the federal court lacked jurisdiction. The two decisions address different questions: Broderick’s concerned whether the case could be heard in federal court, while Schofield considered whether the CFTC had established grounds for an emergency order blocking state enforcement.
New York County Supreme Court Justice Melissa Crane is scheduled to hear Attorney General Letitia James’ request for a temporary restraining order at 11:30 a.m. ET on Nov. 23. The proposed order would bar Kalshi from operating an unlicensed gambling business “within or from New York or to persons in New York.” It would cover contracts tied to sports, culture, elections and other events, according to the reported filing.
The wording has become a point of dispute. Kalshi argues that, because it is headquartered in New York, a ban on operating “from New York” could effectively shut its exchange nationwide and require liquidation of open positions. James’ office says it is not seeking to close the exchange everywhere. The state-court hearing will address the request for temporary relief; the available account does not indicate what Justice Crane will decide or how any order would be framed.
The CFTC’s position is also being pursued in a separate federal lawsuit. Filed by the agency and the Justice Department in April, that case challenges New York’s actions, and the CFTC’s request for a preliminary injunction remained pending as of Nov. 20. Schofield’s denial of the emergency request therefore does not dispose of the agency’s broader litigation.
The dispute sits within a developing disagreement among federal appeals courts over the boundary between federal commodities regulation and state authority over gambling. The Block reported Nov. 21 that the Fourth, Sixth and Ninth Circuits have sided with states, while the Third Circuit has sided with Kalshi. That split underscores that the governing rule is not uniform nationwide; it does not, by itself, determine how New York’s case will be resolved.
A related Nov. 10 ruling by U.S. District Judge Colleen McMahon also figured in the arguments. McMahon described the CFTC’s Aug. 11 emergency order protecting Kalshi from state enforcement as potentially “a collusive effort between a regulator and regulatee,” a characterization New York cited in opposing the CFTC’s renewed request.
For now, the practical consequence is limited but significant: the CFTC has not secured a federal order preventing New York from pressing its case, and the state’s request for a temporary restraining order is set for a hearing. The central legal questions—how far the Commodity Exchange Act displaces state gaming rules and what restrictions New York may impose on Kalshi—remain unresolved in the proceedings described so far.

